Stages of a Personal Injury Lawsuit: Trial By Steve Charpentier on March 30, 2016

A judge and a gavelThe experienced accident attorneys of Charpentier Law Firm have helped countless clients in the greater Melbourne area. Their diligence extends beyond the courtroom, helping clients make smart legal choices given the nature of their case.

We've covered the various stages of a personal injury lawsuit, looking at the initial paperwork and working through the pre-trial phases. Let's now consider the basics of the trial itself and what that entails.

The Jury Selection Process

If your case is going to a jury trial rather than one tried only before a judge, the first step will be to select the jury. During jury selection, the attorneys will ask the pool of potential jurors a series of questions to gauge their personalities, assess objectivity, and weed out any potential biases.

Attorneys can dismiss a set amount of jurors for different reasons. For instance, jurors may be dismissed due to a perceived inability to be objective ("challenges for cause") or for any reason at all ("peremptory challenges").

Opening Statements by the Attorneys

The actual trial itself will begin with the attorneys making their opening statements. The plaintiff's attorney will typically go first, laying out the nature of the case for the jury and state what is trying to be proven in the case. The defendant's attorney will then make an opening statement offering their own interpretation of the events of the case and what they will set out to prove.

If a lawsuit has more than two parties involved, there will be additional opening statements made.

Witnesses: Direct Examination, Cross-Examination, Re-Direct Examination

This main portion of the trial is known as the "case-in-chief," and most people know about this process thanks to its portrayal in film and television.

When a witness is called to the stand and is sworn in to testify under oath, the following will then occur:

  • Direct Examination – The plaintiff's attorney will ask the witness questions to support their case.

  • Cross-Examination – The defendant's attorney will ask their own set of questions in an attempt to rebut or call into question the information revealed to the jury in direct examination.

  • Re-Direct Examination – The plaintiff's attorney will have a final chance to address the doubts the defendant's attorney raised during cross-examination.

The process continues until the plaintiff's side rests. The defendant's side then has the opportunity for direct examination of their own witness, whom the plaintiff's side can cross-examine, with the process unfolding in a fashion similar to the one noted above.

Closing Arguments by the Attorneys

In closing arguments, the attorneys for the plaintiff and the defendant are able to restate their case fir the jury and emphasize any evidence or testimony during the trial. In many cases, the plaintiff's side makes their closing arguments first, and both sides try to be as persuasive as possible.

The Judge Instructs the Jury

After closing arguments, the judge will provide legal guidelines and considerations to the jury with regard to the case. This will help outline certain concerns of which the jury should be attentive while they discuss the case in deliberation.

Jury Deliberation

Jury deliberation is a private discussion among the jurors alone in which the case and its evidence is discussed. The jury may request evidence to be re-examined or that part of the court transcript be provided as they go over the information they've heard. During this time, they will determine if the defendant should be held accountable and what damages should be awarded in the case.

Delivering the Trial Verdict

The verdict of a case is read in court with the various parties present. In some cases, a jury may be hung, meaning that they could not reach a unanimous decision or plurality. In these cases, a judge may declare a mistrial, which would involve a new trial being done.

Contact Our Personal Injury Lawyers

To learn more about trials, settlements, and other aspects of a lawsuit, be sure to contact our personal injury law firm today. The attorneys of Charpentier Law Firm are here to help you make sound and confident legal decisions.

Related to This

Charpentier Law Firm, P.A. office building

Charpentier Law Firm, P.A.

Since 1989, Stephen G. Charpentier been protecting victims' rights. Mr. Charpentier:

  • Is a recipient of an AV rating, the Martindale-Hubbel®
  • National Law Directory's highest honor
  • Earned Florida Legal Elite status in 2010
  • Handles cases in many practice areas including medical malpractice, auto accidents, and wrongful death

To schedule your free consultation, contact us online or call us at (321) 308-8020.

Get In Touch Today

Rate, Review & Explore

Social Accounts Sprite

Melbourne Office

2290 W Eau Gallie Blvd
Ste 212
Melbourne, FL 32935

Closed Today

Cocoa Office

1980 Michigan Ave
Cocoa, FL 32922

Closed Today

Titusville Office

719 Garden St
Titusville, FL 32796

Closed Today

What is the best time for you?

Add additional time

Which location would you prefer?

Tell us a bit about yourself...

(321) 308-8020 Send a message